I first became aware of Regina Doman and her Fairy Tale Novels through fellow blogger Elenatintil, whom I found on NarniaWeb.
Authored by Catholic home-schooling mother Regina Doman, the Fairy Tale Novels are a series of books that take classic fairy tales and retell them in a modern setting. Currently there are 4: The Shadow of the Bear (Snow White and Rose Red), Black As Night (Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs), Waking Rose (Sleeping Beauty) and The Midnight Dancers (the Twelve Dancing Princesses). The latter has yet to make it to my bookshelf, by the way.
The Shadow of the Bear, Black As Night and Waking Rose follow the lives of two sisters, Blanche and Rose Brier. The first book splits the focus pretty evenly between the two sisters; however Black As Night is solely Blanche’s story as Waking Rose is Rose’s.
Pros
I enjoyed these books. While not absolutely astounding pieces of literature, they were enjoyable, good reads; definitely worth the money spent on them. Doman has a good grasp of character and a talent for making situations feel real. In particular, I loved Fish/Benedict Denniston. Now there is a character after my own heart: a slightly sarcastic fellow with a quick-fire wit and a tongue to express it.
One of the greatest things about these books is the wholesome worldview they present. The characters and author insist upon the beauty of living your life for God. Morality isn’t stifling and holiness isn’t drab.
Cons
While I enjoyed these books, I did find a few areas where I thought they were lacking.
- Important parts of the fairy tales skipped over
- “Catholic”, not “Christian”
1. The fairy tale “Snow White and Rose Red”, has many themes. One is compatibility in companionship: a theme that is very well expressed in The Shadow of the Bear. But there are other themes, themes that got left behind. In the fairy tale, the girls live in the forest where they know every creature, every flower. They are comfortable in their environment; they wander where they please, taking no thought for their safety, because they know nothing will harm them. Even Snow White, the shy and quiet sister has no fear of the forest or the inhabitants.
In The Shadow of the Bear, the girls are new arrivals to the city. They have few or no friends, and Blanche is anything but comfortable with her environment.
There are, of course, many lessons to be learned from those who are adjusting to their environment. But they are not the lessons of this fairy tale.
Also, the encounters with the “dwarf” (a major part of the original fairy tale) felt like it was squeezed in.
I had the same trouble with Waking Rose. It just didn’t feel like Sleeping Beauty.
One of the reasons Black As Night was my favorite out of the three was that it truly was Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs retold in the modern world. All the major points of the fairy tale were represented, and several quiet nods to the source material peppered the background.
2. The biggest trouble I had with the fairy tale novels is that the characters and worldview are defined as “Catholic”. Not once in the first three books is the word “Christian” used. It’s always “Catholic”. Is the wholesome outlook Doman presents Catholic, or is it Christian?
Oh, I call myself Presbyterian, and I am, fiercely and completely. But Presbyterian comes after and only after Christian. The “Christian” part defines my life, and is my worldview. “Presbyterian” is for those little details, which sometimes give more trouble than the big, important ones. To me, acknowledging our unity in the redeeming blood of Christ seems like it ought to come first, before we proclaim our allegiance to a particular branch of the visible church.
I am planning on getting The Midnight Dancers when I get a spare $25, and Alex O’Donnell and the 40 Hackers when it comes out. And I would love to see Doman write something in a different genre, outside of her comfort zone.